- Letter to the Editor
- Open Access
Calu-3 epithelial cells exhibit different immune and epithelial barrier responses from freshly isolated primary nasal epithelial cells in vitro
Clinical and Translational Allergy volume 8, Article number: 40 (2018)
Epithelial cell lines are often used to evaluate the effect of exogenous/endogenous stimuli on epithelial barrier function and innate immune responses in allergic airway diseases, without clear view on differences between epithelial cell lines and primary nasal epithelial cell responses. In this observational study, we compared the response of Calu-3 and primary nasal epithelial cells to two relevant exogenous stimuli: i.e. Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxin B (SEB) and house dust mite (HDM). Stimulation of Calu-3 cells with SEB decreased epithelial integrity in a dose dependent manner, which was associated with a significant increase in IL-6 and IL-8 production. In contrast, no alteration in barrier integrity or IL-6 and IL-8 production was seen when primary nasal epithelial cells were stimulated with SEB. HDM extract altered the integrity of primary nasal epithelial cells, but not of Calu-3 epithelial cells. Increased IL-8 production was seen after stimulation with HDM in primary nasal epithelial cells and not in Calu-3 epithelial cells. In conclusion, immune and barrier function differ between different epithelial cell types studied. As a consequence, care must be taken when interpreting data using different epithelial cell types.
Airway epithelial cells serve as the first site of contact to exogenous stimuli such as dust, pollutants or microorganisms. Consequently, airway epithelial cells present a dual function, i.e. preventing the invasion of foreign particles by creating a physical barrier and defending the body by inducing an appropriate immune response. Inter-epithelial junctions like tight junctions seal off the paracellular space between the airway epithelial cells and thus protect the internal environment from the penetration of possible harmful substances [1, 2]. Previous studies revealed disturbed expression and regulation of tight junctions with impaired epithelial barrier function in asthma and allergic rhinitis [3, 4]. Consequently, studying the regulation of airway epithelial barrier function by exogenous and/or endogenous stimuli has become a major interest in better understanding the pathology of multiple airway diseases. Beside from primary bronchial or nasal epithelial cells, immortalized epithelial cell lines such as Calu-3, 16HBE or T84 cells are often used . Despite the easy maintenance and unlimited amount of cells, epithelial cell lines differ in cellular responses, morphology and biochemical characteristics compared to primary nasal epithelial cells. Hence, care must be taken when interpreting data generated using cell lines as they might respond differently compared to primary nasal epithelial cells.
In this study, we report differences in response of Calu-3 epithelial cells to exogenous stimuli Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxin B (SEB) and house dust mite (HDM) extract compared to primary nasal epithelial cells. SEB has immunomodulatory properties in allergic airway disease  and can modulate barrier integrity of the intestinal epithelial cell line, T84 cells . Details on methodology are provided in an Additional file 1. Therefore, we first evaluated the effect of SEB on epithelial barrier integrity in vitro. Air–liquid interface (ALI) cultures of freshly isolated primary nasal epithelial cells and Calu-3 epithelial cells were stimulated for 4 h with different concentrations of SEB (1 µg and 10 µg). Stimulation with SEB constitutively decreased trans-epithelial electrical resistance (TER) of ALI cultures of Calu-3 epithelial cells in a dose and time dependent manner (Fig. 1a). In parallel, diffusion of FITC-dextran 4 kDa (FD4) across the epithelial monolayer, as a surrogate marker for paracellular permeability, was significantly increased at time point 4 h with the highest concentration of SEB (10 µg) (Fig. 1a). On the contrary, when ALI cultures from primary nasal epithelial cells were stimulated for 4 h with SEB, no effect on TER or FD4 permeability was observed (Fig. 1b). Additionally, exposure of epithelial cells to SEB promotes the secretion of pro-inflammatory cytokines such as IL-6 and IL-8 . SEB stimulation of Calu-3 epithelial cells significantly increased the release of IL-6 and IL-8, while SEB had no effect on cytokine secretion from primary nasal epithelial cells (Fig. 1c). This data demonstrates that SEB affects epithelial integrity and cytokine secretion of Calu-3 epithelial cell cultures, which is not seen in primary nasal epithelial cell cultures.
We next evaluated the effect of HDM on the two different epithelial cell culture systems. HDM is the most common allergen in allergic rhinitis and contains many components that act on airway epithelial cells to disrupt cell–cell contact . ALI cultures of Calu-3 and primary nasal epithelial cells were stimulated with different concentrations of HDM extract (0.2, 2 and 20 µg) for 4 h. HDM did not alter TER nor FD4 permeability in ALI cultures from Calu-3 epithelial cells (Fig. 2a). However, HDM disrupted epithelial barrier integrity of ALI cultures of primary nasal epithelial cells in a dose dependent manner (Fig. 2b). In line, FD4 permeability was increased with increasing dose of HDM extract (Fig. 2b). Lastly, we evaluated the effect of HDM on cytokine production (i.e. IL-6, IL-8 and TNF-α) of epithelial cells and found that HDM did not alter IL-8 production in Calu-3 epithelial cells, while IL-8 production of primary nasal epithelial cells was elevated without reaching significance (Fig. 2c). TNF-α and IL-6 production was below detection limit for both Calu-3 and primary nasal epithelial cells (data not shown). Collectively, HDM extract impaired epithelial barrier function of primary nasal epithelial cells but not of calu-3 cells.
In the present study, we show a different response of Calu-3 epithelial cells to SEB and HDM extract compared to primary nasal epithelial cells. SEB is a superantigen with immune-modulatory and pro-inflammatory effects that can aggravate allergic airway responses . In this study, stimulation of Calu-3 epithelial cells with SEB decreased barrier integrity, which was not found in primary nasal epithelial cell cultures. The decrease in barrier integrity in the Calu-3 cells was associated with an increase in IL-6 and IL-8 production. On the other hand, HDM extract impaired barrier integrity of primary nasal epithelial cells, which is in line with previous published work . Surprisingly, HDM extract could not impair Calu-3 epithelial integrity, nor alter cytokine production both in Calu-3 and primary epithelial cells. We believe that these differences are associated with altered biochemical and cellular properties after immortalization of Calu-3 epithelial cells. At ALI, Calu-3 epithelial cells form a confluent, polarized monolayer with tight junction expression and a uniform mucus layer. However, we have some evidence that expression of tight junction varies in Calu-3 epithelial cells compared to primary nasal epithelial cells, which might explain the different responses to SEB and HDM. Moreover, the presence of ciliated cells and innate pattern recognition receptors on Calu-3 cells is contradictory, and thus can influence epithelial cytokine production . Of note, our findings are only applicable to Calu-3 epithelial cells. The effect of exogenous stimuli on other airway epithelial cell lines has not been investigated.
In conclusion, care must be taken when studying epithelial barrier function and immune responses using epithelial cell lines as they differ in cellular responses compared to primary epithelial cells. We therefore propose, depending on the scientific research question and the availability of patient material, to use freshly isolated primary nasal epithelial cells, as disease-related processes can easily be studied and thus will provide a better understanding of the pathology of different airway diseases.
Georas SN, Rezaee F. Epithelial barrier function: at the front line of asthma immunology and allergic airway inflammation. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2014;134(3):509–20.
Steelant B, Seys SF, Boeckxstaens G, Akdis CA, Ceuppens JL, Hellings PW. Restoring airway epithelial barrier dysfunction: a new therapeutic challenge in allergic airway disease. Rhinology. 2016;54(3):195–205.
Xiao C, Puddicombe SM, Field S, Haywood J, Broughton-Head V, Puxeddu I, et al. Defective epithelial barrier function in asthma. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2011;128(3):549–56 (e1-12).
Steelant B, Farre R, Wawrzyniak P, Belmans J, Dekimpe E, Vanheel H, et al. Impaired barrier function in patients with house dust mite-induced allergic rhinitis is accompanied by decreased occludin and zonula occludens-1 expression. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2016;137(4):1043–1053 e5.
Patou J, Gevaert P, Van Zele T, Holtappels G, van Cauwenberge P, Bachert C. Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxin B, protein A, and lipoteichoic acid stimulations in nasal polyps. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2008;121(1):110–5.
Yan H, Yi H, Xia L, Zhan Z, He W, Cao J, et al. Staphylococcal enterotoxin B suppresses Alix and compromises intestinal epithelial barrier functions. J Biomed Sci. 2014;21:29.
Huvenne W, Callebaut I, Plantinga M, Vanoirbeek JA, Krysko O, Bullens DM, et al. Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxin B facilitates allergic sensitization in experimental asthma. Clin Exp Allergy. 2010;40(7):1079–90.
Post S, Nawijn MC, Hackett TL, Baranowska M, Gras R, van Oosterhout AJ, et al. The composition of house dust mite is critical for mucosal barrier dysfunction and allergic sensitisation. Thorax. 2012;67(6):488–95.
Post S, Nawijn MC, Jonker MR, Kliphuis N, van den Berge M, van Oosterhout AJ, et al. House dust mite-induced calcium signaling instigates epithelial barrier dysfunction and CCL20 production. Allergy. 2013;68(9):1117–25.
Grainger CI, Greenwell LL, Lockley DJ, Martin GP, Forbes B. Culture of Calu-3 cells at the air interface provides a representative model of the airway epithelial barrier. Pharm Res. 2006;23(7):1482–90.
KM and BS performed experiments and KM wrote the manuscript. BP, PWH and BS critically revised and edited the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Consent for publication
Ethical approval and consent to participate
Ethical approval was obtained from the medical ethical committee at the University Hospitals Leuven, Belgium for the isolation of primary nasal epithelial cells from residual material.
The author’s laboratories are supported by Grants from the Belgian Federal Government (IUAP P7/30), IWT (TBM Project 130260) and the research council of the KU Leuven (GOA 2009/07 and 14/011). P.W.H. received a senior researcher fellowship from the Fund of Scientific Research (FWO), Flanders, Belgium. B.S. is currently a Postdoctoral Fellow of the Fund for Scientific Research Flanders (FWO).
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Martens, K., Hellings, P.W. & Steelant, B. Calu-3 epithelial cells exhibit different immune and epithelial barrier responses from freshly isolated primary nasal epithelial cells in vitro. Clin Transl Allergy 8, 40 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13601-018-0225-8
- Primary nasal epithelial cells
- Calu-3 epithelial cell line
- House dust mite extract
- Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxin B
- Trans-epithelial electrical resistance